Sunday, March 2, 2008

THE SICKENING MEDIA


What is the job of the media? What is the responsibility of the media? The job of a responsible media is to put things across people exactly as they have happened, give a complete coverage of all the facts and let people decide what is correct and what is wrong. What does the Indian media (especially the news channels) do these days? The news channels do exactly the opposite. They blow everything out of proportion, make a controversial story out of it, and present only those things which give some credence to their story and hence persuade people to believe in it by showing the same audio visuals again and again. This is the sickening reality of India’s media today.

Let us put some of the happenings in the ongoing tri series involving India-Australia-Srilanka into perspective. It all started even before the series got under way. The Indian ODI team was selected after India pulled of a historic win in the Perth test. The selectors, along with Dhoni went for youth and exuberance over some of the experienced but a bit old and jaded players like Dravid and Ganguly. Infact, the only significant exclusion was Ganguly because Dravid was not there in last ODI series either and also looked out of touch in the test series. But there was this massive hue and cry created by the media over this exclusion. The news channels made stories suggesting Dhoni played politics, Dhoni didn’t want to play under the influence of former captains, that the young inexperienced team would collapse under pressure and even went to the extent of saying that the team would lose the edge as a unit (The same team is 1-0 up in the best of 3 finals!!!). When questioned about the selection, Dhoni didn’t mince words and clearly said that he wanted youngsters (who could field and run well between the wickets) on the big Australian grounds and his word was taken in the selection. When Dravid was at the helm under Coach Greg Chappell, everyone criticized Dravid for being too shy of voicing his opinion and capitulating under the pressure of Greg during team selection. But, here was a man who had his say in selection and didn’t shy away from media in accepting the same. Unfortunately, the media made him the bad boy.

Moving on, as our top 5 batsmen were not scoring enough runs in the first half of the series, Dhoni, when asked about the lack of form of top order, made a frank statement that if Viru, Sachin our top 5 get good partnerships, then it would be much easier for him and Uthappa to come down the order and play freely which was not happening in the series up to then. Again the channels stepped in to create another controversy saying that Dhoni now had Viru, Sachin on his radar, that he was now planning to get them out of the team and other similar rubbish. I couldn’t understand what actually they wanted: A diplomatic laid back captain or a straightforward frank captain…

Quite a few people had expressed concerns about Sachin’s form in the series. The harshest comment came from Sanjay Manjerekar who described Sachin as an elephant in the room whom no one had the courage to talk about and Sachin’s failure must be addressed. Just before India’s crucial match (virtual semifinal) against Srilanka, Tendulkar was interviewed by the Star Sports Team. When asked whether he was concerned about his form, he denied and I believe, made a straight dig at Manjerekar saying that sometimes people tend to react more than they should.

Tendulkar played an important innings in the match helping India reach the finals. Now instead of celebrating the fact that this young Indian team had reached the finals by playing some good cricket, one of the news channels(INDIA TV) named their half an hour post match show as ‘Dhoni Ko Tamacha’ with Dhoni’s and Sachin’s pics facing each other. The channel tried to prove that Sachin wanted to teach Dhoni a lesson. It tried to prove that Sachin’s comment in the morning was aimed at Dhoni and his knock would silence Dhoni from criticizing him (Actually Dhoni never singled out Sachin in his comments). I want to ask INDIA TV whether Sachin played that knock because he was (in their opinion) targeted by Dhoni. Was Sachin just playing for the sake of playing in the earlier matches? Was Sachin’s knock to silence Dhoni or help India reach the finals? There is no way in this wide world that INDIA TV would have an answer to these questions. That half an hour, they just went on trying to prove their baseless senseless story instead of praising the team for an emphatic victory. That was the moment I could not stop myself from going all holds barred against the media. This is something that does not just happen in cricket. It is pretty much the case in every field.

It is high time now that the media understands its responsibility and become a boon for the country, which I must say, is heading in a totally opposite direction at the moment.

4 comments:

Raju Gupta said...

I fully endorse your views Vyom. In fact the so called news channels telecast everything but news. Only motive of such channels is to create propaganda, to scandalize even the most harmless incidence or some one's saying. These channels believe in,"continuous hammering of a lie turns it in to a truth"
Stories about Dhoni blaming Sachin and so on are simply trash and should be treated as such.
TO sum up I appreciate the clarity with which you have brought out your thoughts. the language is fluent and shows you have developed good communication skills. keep it up. Blogs on other current topics would be still more appreciated.

Love
papa

Ankit Poddar said...

pretty much a very complete post on the relationship between cricket and media... however once i read the title i was of a view that the post is going to be more media centric than cricket centric while i found the opposite in your post.

i think you can write as well on topics other than cricket.. so do that my friend.

SDS said...

A very true and comprehensive write-up, probably what you have written vyom, is the plea of every indian to the media.

However, if you put yourself in the shoes of the news channel people, there are certain aspects which have shades of grey. Now, when you talk of media, it is a very wide term and it nowhere says that its only facts you are allowed to give.
Further, you are free to express your views whatever they may be.
Also, news channels are business ventures, this is just their bid to make their stuff sell. You dont subscribe to it, and they give you all the chance to switch to another channel.
It is what you call, they give you not only the facts but also footage to direct your thoughts in the 'correct' direction.

anyways, this is just to argue. i fully agree with your views, and i think no matter what, the indian cricket team should get due credit. its high time!!

Unknown said...

Hmmm,

as some1 already pointed out above, YOU haven't done justice to the topic chosen. Also Media I believe in your dictionary is limited to Tv? How about Print ...

I wouldn't really play the devils advocate here, but isn't it the media's job to air the views and concerns of all the sections of the society?

Were all the sections of the cricketing fraternity happy with the exclusion of Dravid and Dada?

Yes I would agree that a few channels are promoting scandalous news. And making a controversy gets them TRP. Morally its wrong, But with so many news channels going around all of them need to make some $$$!

Just a little glance over your blog tells me about your passion for cricket, and I appreciate that you have taken that to learn about the real world. Keep it up, and Keep Posting. No matter how busy you are, a Post a week is nothing difficult.

Annkur